Skip to main content

Indianapolis Colts at Pittsburgh Steelers Odds & Game Pick

by November 1, 2019

Whether you’re new to sports betting or a betting pro, our Sports Betting Strategy and Advice page is for you. You can get started with our 101 section — including How to Choose a Sportsbook — or head to more advanced strategy — like Which Sports Are Most Profitable to Bet? — to learn more.

The Steelers started the season 0-3, and it seemed like the sky was falling in Pittsburgh. Adjustments were made, and the team responded by going 3-1 over their last four games. The defense has looked solid over that span, while the offense has been able to get the job done with strong efforts from running back James Conner. 

Meanwhile, the Colts have been playing some pretty good football as well. Winners of three straight, Indianapolis has apparently found their rhythm defensively. They limited Patrick Mahomes and the Chiefs to just 13 points several weeks ago, and they’ll look to feast on the inconsistencies of backup quarterback Mason Rudolph on Sunday. 

Special Offer: Bet $1 and win $100 if New England Patriots score a point this week >>


  • Opening Lines: The spread has held after opening at Colts -1. The over/under has dropped since opening at 43.5.
  • Current Line: Colts -1 FanDuel Sportsbook
  • O/U: 42 at FanDuel Sportsbook
  • Location: Heinz Field – Pittsburgh, PA 
  • Start Time: 1:00pm ET
  • Television: CBS
  • Last Meeting: November 12, 2017 – Steelers defeated the Colts 20-17 in Indianapolis

View consensus picks from 100+ experts for the Colts at Steelers >>


The biggest factor heading into this game revolves around the health of Steelers running back James Conner. He’s currently questionable with a shoulder injury, and backup running back Benny Snell has been ruled out. Running back Jaylen Samuels is on track to play after missing Monday’s tilt with the Dolphins, but a potential lack of depth at this critical position could prove worrisome if Conner doesn’t play. 

On the other side, T.Y. Hilton is questionable with a calf injury. This isn’t anything to get overly concerned about, as Hilton still has a reasonable chance to suit up on Sunday. Still, it’s something we’ll need to monitor as we move closer to the game. The loss of a playmaker on either side could be the difference in this tightly-contested game.

Editor’s Note: T.Y. Hilton has since been ruled out for Sunday’s game.


  • The Panthers are 7-3 ATS against the AFC over the past two years.
  • The Titans are 7-3 ATS against the NFC over the past two years.
  • The Panthers are 7-3 to the over against the AFC since 2017. 
  • The Titans are 7-3 to the over against the NFC since 2017. 

Prop Bets

Colts -1 & Under 42 (+200)
I rarely look to these spread/total parlays, but this one has a pretty good chance to hit. As mentioned earlier, both defenses are playing great at the moment, and I believe that will continue on Sunday. The Steelers are dealing with injuries to their skill positions, which could help the Colts pull through in a low-scoring battle. 

Bottom Line

I believe the Colts are the more resilient team at this stage in the season. They haven’t been phased by playing on the road this season, picking up gutsy victories over the Titans and Chiefs in their last two contests away from home. They should get another on Sunday. 

Pick: Colts -1 at FanDuel Sportsbook

FanDuel Sportsbook: View our review and access special sports betting offers >>

Check out our other NFL Sports Betting Guides for Week 9

Houston Texans at Jacksonville Jaguars (+1.5)
Chicago Bears at Philadelphia Eagles (-4)
Washington Redskins at Buffalo Bills (-10.5)
New York Jets at Miami Dolphins (+3.5)
Tennessee Titans at Carolina Panthers (-3.5)
Minnesota Vikings at Kansas City Chiefs (+2.5)
Tampa Bay Buccaneers at Seattle Seahawks (-5.5)
Detroit Lions at Oakland Raiders (-2.5)
Cleveland Browns at Denver Broncos (+4)
Green Bay Packers at Los Angeles Chargers (+3.5)
New England Patriots at Baltimore Ravens (+3)
Dallas Cowboys at New York Giants (+7)

Spencer Limbach is a featured writer at BettingPros and FantasyPros. For more from Spencer, check out his archive and follow him @spencer_jl.

Game Previews, NFL, Picks